Vick versus the Volcano
Many believed that Michael Vick would be the next superstar of the NFL.
Michael Vick was my favorite non Patriots and Browns (yes they are my second favorite team…..long story) player. He was like Barry Sanders at the QB position. He had amazing runs that left defenders grasping at the air. He was the face, heart, and soul of the Atlanta Falcons. He was the next superstar in the NFL.
I saw him play live twice against the Patriots in 2001 taking over for an injured Chris Chandler. He didn’t do much getting smothered by the Patriots D. I also saw him play against Seattle in 2002. The Falcons won and he had a great deal to do with it. He was a magician and leader, I was hooked.
After his epic playoff win versus Green Bay at Lambeau, I thought he was going to be a star for years to come. I bought his jersey, bobble head, and rookie trading cards. I was officially a member of Mike Vick Nation.
I followed his career; he continued his amazing runs while polishing his throwing skills. In 2005, he led the Falcons to NFC Championship game against the Philadelphia Eagles (ironically enough the team that he is now a member of).
The sky was limit for him. He broke the QB rushing record in 2006. Then his world, career, and reputation became tainted forever.
He was indicted on dog fighting charges. He trained them. Gambled on them. Tortured them and in the end, killed them. There is no doubt; he hung out with the wrong crowd.
However, I was shocked, appalled, and downright disgusted about his decisions and actions. How could any human being do this to an animal? It was downright cruel and inhumane.
My respect and admiration for the athlete died. I tossed my jerseys in disgust and his collectibles are in storage somewhere. Would he ever overcome this travesty? Would he ever return to the NFL?
After two years of incarceration and much soul searching, Michael Vick has been given a second chance.
It will be interesting to see how Michael Vick is used by Andy Reid and the Philadelphia Eagles.
The Philadelphia Eagles signed him to a 2 year deal this past Thursday. Does he deserve a second chance? Yes. He did his time and took his punishment. I can respect that, but won’t forget what he has done. Hopefully, he will partake in more community service and help put the memories to sleep. I think he can.
He deserves a fair chance and all the haters need to give him that.
It bewilders me that Donte Stallworth who was drunk, drove, and killed a man, is getting less flak than Vick.
Both deeds were unthinkable, but why should Stallworth be given a free pass because the victim’s family took the money and he only did 4 weeks in jail? I don’t see any signs with Stallworth’s number with a slash through it. I don’t see anyone outside Stallworth’s house with signs with “Drunk Driver” or “Murderer”.
If Vick is going to be thrown into the volcano so should Stallworth. They both deserve second chances, but need to be treated the same way. They are human and made terrible mistakes. Let them make good again. Good luck gentlemen.
Joe Gill is a regular contributor to Sports Then and Now. You can read his column “Cup of Joe” every Tuesday and Thursday on Boston Sports Then and Now.
Joe,
Nice piece. I think there are two big differences between the Stallworth and Vick situations.
First is that while being involved in someone's death (especially when having been drinking) is horrible, it is something that unfortunately happens regularly in this country and while not necessarily accepted, is generally regarded as being an accident (though you certainly could argue that after all these years of education people should know better). Stallworth is not the first person of note to be involved in this kind of situation as it has happened to lawyers, doctors, housewives and many others. Anyone who has gotten behind the wheel of a car when a little bit drunk knows it could happen to them (which is why designated drivers is among the world's best inventions).
On the other hand, what Vick did was so far out of the norm for most people that I think the violence and cruelty of it shocked and angered many people.
Secondly, while Vick spent weeks telling lies to the media, NFL, Falcons and authorities, Stallworth was completely up front and owned his situation from the very beginning. He called the cops, stayed at the scene, admitted his mistake and has been completely upstanding about the situation. That is a far cry not just from how Vick originally acted, but also from how other pro athletes have when caught doing something wrong or illegal.
I am not versed on DUI cases to know if Stallworth's prison sentence was consistent or less than other cases. I know my wife witnessed an accident where someone with a history of drinking (and open containers in the car) hit and killed a women yet got off with no jail time. And he wasn't an NFL star.
I think suspending Stallworth for the season was the right thing for Goodell to do and Stallworth has continued to be above board about the entire thing. He may have made an awful mistake, but you can see that he is learning from it and not hiding behind his NFL stardom.
I agree with you that both Vick and Stallworth have paid their price and deserve second chances. I hope Vick does well in Philly and I hope next season Stallworth is given a shot by another team.
I agree with alot of what you said Dean but Vick did his time and Stallworth got off pretty easy if you ask me.
You need to really moderate the comments here