Posted on
November 16, 2019 by
Dean Hybl
One of the cool parts of the NFL celebrating 100 years in
2019 is remembering the great moments and players that have helped shape the
history of the game.
The NFL Network has been sharing their selections for the
top moments, game-changers, teams and characters. Soon they will be unveiling
their list of the top 100 players in NFL history.
In a sport that has seen great change and evolution over 100
years, creating any comprehensive all-time list is going to be subjective and
open to interpretation.
That is likely even more pronounced when trying to choose
the top 100 players of the NFL’s first 100 years.
Some will certainly rely heavily on statistics as a guide,
but my opinion is that while individual season statistics and the number of
seasons leading the league in a statistical category can help identify
greatness, career and all-time statistics are not as helpful and can be
misleading when trying to pick an all-time team.
Whether it is related to the number of games played each
season, move from playing both ways to position specialization or rule changes
that impact offensive production, there has been enough change over the history
of the game that I believe reduce the importance of career statistics.
That is why for the
Sports Then and Now list of the Top 100 Players in NFL history we chose to give
greater emphasis to other factors. The things we looked at when choosing our
top 100 included All-Pro and Pro Bowl selections, number of times leading their
league in statistical categories, how they compared to other players from
within their era and peak performance. Team success was given greater weight in
ordering quarterbacks, but played only a minor role in selecting players from
other positions.
The result is a Sports Then and Now Top 100 list that I
fully expect to look very different than the list that will be unveiled on the
NFL Network beginning on November 22nd. For our list, we made sure
not to forget those players from the 1920s-1950s whose career statistics are
well below players from future decades, but who were clearly all-time greats.
The distribution of players by era for the ST&N Top 100
is very interesting: 1920s-1930s: 8; 1940s-1950s: 13; 1960s: 24; 1970s: 15;
1980s: 12; 1990s: 12; 2000s: 8; 2010s: 7. However, 14 of our top 20 played a
majority of their career after 1980.
This is the first of four posts over the next couple weeks
announcing the ST&N Top 100. This one includes players 100-76.
100. Larry Wilson –
St. Louis Cardinals – 8 Pro Bowls; 5 time 1st Team All-Pro: The
creator of the safety blitz, Wilson was a hard-nosed player who was one of the
top defensive players of the 1960s. He registered 52 career interceptions and
scored seven defensive touchdowns during his career.
99. J.J. Watt –
Houston Texans – 5 Pro Bowls, 5 time 1st Team All-Pro: When
healthy, J.J. Watt has clearly distinguished himself as an all-time great. He
has earned first-team All-Pro in each of the five seasons in which he has been
healthy throughout the year and was named the NFL Defensive Player of the Year
three times in his first four years. Unfortunately, a recent injury that has
ended his 2019 season marks the third time in the last four years that he has
played in eight or fewer games.
98. Adrian Peterson –
Minnesota Vikings (primary team) – 7 Pro Bowls; 4 time 1st team
All-Pro: A three-time NFL rushing champion, Adrian Peterson was the most
dominant running back in the NFL during his 10 seasons in Minnesota. After
suffering a major knee injury in 2011, the next season he rushed for 2,097
yards, which is the second highest single season total in NFL history.
97. Derrick Brooks –
Tampa Bay Buccaneers – 11 Pro Bowls; 5 time 1st team All-Pro:
Often over-shadowed by more flamboyant teammates, Derrick Brooks was the steady
leader of a Tampa Bay defense that was among the best in the league for nearly
a decade. In their Super Bowl winning season in 2002, Brooks was the NFL
Defensive Player of the Year as he returned three interceptions for touchdowns
during the regular season and had another score in the Super Bowl.
Read the rest of this entry →